Comparisons · Personal Finance · 2026-11-20
Actual Budget vs Sure: Measured RAM, Stack Complexity, and VPS Cost
Head-to-head self-hosting comparison of Actual Budget (148.4 MB, 1 container) and Sure (798.3 MB, 4 containers) based on our sandbox Docker Compose benchmarks.
Actual Budget
actualbudget/actual- Idle RAM
- 148.4 MB
- Containers
- 1
- Startup
- 60.3 s
- VPS tier
- 1 GB VPS
- actual
148.4 MB
Sure Personal Finance
we-promise/sure- Idle RAM
- 798.3 MB
- Containers
- 4
- Startup
- 77.6 s
- VPS tier
- 2 GB VPS
- web
381.1 MB - worker
367.7 MB - db
39.0 MB - redis
10.5 MB
Both Actual Budget and Sure let you keep personal financial records on hardware you control, without handing bank exports or net-worth history to a SaaS subscription. On paper they sit in the same category; in a Docker sandbox they behave like two completely different classes of software.
In our verified runs, Sure used 5.4× as much idle memory as Actual Budget (798.3 MB vs 148.4 MB) and required four containers instead of one. That difference determines whether your finance app shares a $5/month 1 GB VPS alongside other tools, or demands a 2 GB tier of its own.
Why the 5.4× RAM gap exists
The container breakdown explains almost the entire gap:
- Actual Budget (148.4 MB total) runs a single Node.js sync server (
actualbudget/actual-server:latest). Budget files and SQLite state sit directly in a/datavolume, while most UI calculation happens locally in the browser or desktop client. There is no external database, no Redis broker, and no background worker process. - Sure (798.3 MB total) is a full Ruby on Rails application forked from Maybe Finance. Nearly all of its idle footprint comes from running two full Rails runtimes side by side: the Puma
webcontainer (381.1 MB) and the Sidekiqworkercontainer (367.7 MB). The supporting infrastructure — PostgreSQL 16 (39.0 MB) and Redis 7 (10.5 MB) — accounts for only 6.2% of the stack’s idle RAM.
If you assumed PostgreSQL and Redis were the expensive part of a multi-container stack, the numbers show the opposite here: the Rails web and worker processes alone consume 748.8 MB before a single transaction is imported.
Day-2 operations: backups, secrets, and upgrades
Memory is only half the operational difference. The two stacks also have very different failure modes when you maintain them over a year.
| Operational factor | Actual Budget | Sure |
|---|---|---|
| Containers to monitor | 1 (actual) |
4 (web, worker, db, redis) |
| Persistent volumes | 1 (actual_data at /data) |
2 (postgres-data + app-storage) |
| Required secrets | First-run server password (set in UI) | SECRET_KEY_BASE, POSTGRES_PASSWORD, plus optional SMTP/OpenAI keys |
| Backup workflow | Snapshot /data (or copy SQLite cleanly) |
Consistent pg_dump + archive /rails/storage uploads |
| Secret-loss blast radius | Reset password on host | Losing SECRET_KEY_BASE renders encrypted Active Record data unreadable |
With Actual Budget, backups are a single directory copy and upgrades are a single image pull. With Sure, you must preserve SECRET_KEY_BASE across migrations (it seeds Rails Active Record encryption keys when dedicated encryption variables are unset) and coordinate database dumps with uploaded PDF attachments in app-storage.
Product scope: envelope budgeting vs net-worth platform
The extra memory in Sure is not wasted — it pays for a broader server-side product:
- Actual Budget focuses tightly on zero-based / envelope budgeting and fast local-first sync across devices. Because the client keeps a local copy, it feels instant even on a cheap, distant VPS, and it keeps the server dumb by design.
- Sure covers a wider personal-finance surface: multi-account net-worth tracking, investment holdings and market-data syncs, PDF statement imports processed via background jobs, rules, and optional OpenAI-backed categorization and chat. That background work is why Sidekiq and Redis are part of the baseline stack.
VPS sizing and co-hosting impact
- On a 1 GB VPS: Actual Budget (148.4 MB) fits comfortably alongside a reverse proxy and several lighter services such as Vaultwarden (7.1 MB) and Memos (18.5 MB), still leaving more than half the host RAM free for Linux and spikes. Sure (798.3 MB idle) should not be deployed on a 1 GB VPS — its idle footprint alone crowds out the OS and leaves no margin for PDF imports or Sidekiq jobs.
- On a 2 GB VPS: Sure runs comfortably with room for database growth, background jobs, and a couple of lightweight utilities. Actual Budget on a 2 GB VPS barely registers on
docker stats.
See our 1 GB VPS measured guide and 2 GB VPS measured guide for concrete multi-app memory budgets.
Which one should you self-host?
Choose Actual Budget if:
- You specifically want envelope / zero-based budgeting rather than portfolio tracking.
- You want a single-container Compose stack that runs comfortably on a 1 GB VPS.
- You prefer minimal maintenance: one volume to back up, no Postgres upgrades, and local-first speed.
- Ready to deploy? Follow our Actual Budget Docker Compose guide.
Choose Sure if:
- You want a full replacement for Mint/Monarch/Maybe covering net worth, investments, and statement imports.
- You already have a 2 GB+ VPS and are comfortable running PostgreSQL, Redis, and background workers.
- You want built-in scheduled syncs and optional LLM-assisted categorization.
- Ready to deploy? Follow our Sure Personal Finance Docker Compose guide.